Understanding High-Speed Rail Track: From Ballast to Aerodynamic Innovation

 

Renfe AVE high-speed trains - copyright Paul Langan

An Educational Guide for Canadians on the Evolution of Railway Track Technology

One of the mandates of High-Speed Rail Canada is to educate Canadians on high-speed rail.  I have been at several high-speed rail symposiums and always found the Infrastructure sections of them interesting. 

The ALTO/Cadence high-speed rail project between Ontario-Quebec, offers for the 1st time in Canada, true high-speed rail. But what exactly will that look like and what technology will they use?

I have been on a number of different high-speed rail trains operators in Europe and have looked at different systems around the world. With ALTO suggesting speed of over 300 km/h in sections, the question of what type of ballast system they will use is just one of many that need to be clarified.

As Canada explores expanding its passenger rail network and considers high-speed rail corridors, understanding the fundamental technologies that make modern rail travel possible becomes increasingly important. This article explores the evolution of railway track systems, from traditional ballasted tracks to cutting-edge solutions that enable trains to safely operate at speeds exceeding 300 km/h.

The Foundation: Understanding Rail Bed Components

What is a Rail Bed?

The rail bed (also called the roadbed or trackbed) is the foundation upon which railway tracks are built. It consists of multiple layers designed to distribute the enormous weight and dynamic forces of passing trains down to the natural ground (subgrade). Think of it as the railway's foundation, similar to how a house needs a strong foundation to remain stable.

Sleepers and Railway Ties

The terms sleeper (commonly used in Europe and Commonwealth countries) and railway tie (more common in North America) refer to the same component: the rectangular supports that lie perpendicular to the rails. These critical components:

• Support and hold the rails at the correct distance apart (called the gauge)
• Transfer the weight of trains to the ballast or track foundation
• Maintain track alignment and prevent the rails from moving laterally
• Traditionally made from wood, but increasingly manufactured from concrete or steel for durability

In Canada, you'll typically hear "railway tie," while in technical literature you may encounter "sleeper" more frequently.

Track ballast from around 1920's Fergus Subdivision CN Rail - copyright Paul Langan

Traditional Track: The Role of Ballast

What is Ballast?

Ballast is the layer of crushed stone packed between, below, and around the ties, forming the visible gravel bed you see beneath railway tracks. The stone performs several crucial functions:

Primary Functions:

• Load Distribution: Bears the compression load from ties, rails, and rolling stock
• Stability: Restrains lateral (sideways) movement of the track
• Drainage: Facilitates water drainage to prevent track instability
• Vibration Damping: Absorbs and dissipates energy from passing trains
• Vegetation Control: Prevents plant growth that could compromise track integrity

Material Specifications:

Track Ballast - Public Domain

Ballast stones must be irregular with sharp edges to ensure they interlock properly. Typical ballast materials include crushed stone, washed gravel, or slag. Most railways use ballast depths between 300 and 400 mm, and high-speed lines may require up to 0.5 metres thick.

Advantages of Ballasted Track

Traditional ballasted track has served railways well for over a century due to several advantages:

• Cost-Effective: Lower initial construction costs compared to alternatives
• Flexibility: Easy to adjust track geometry through tamping and leveling
• Proven Technology: Well-understood maintenance procedures
• Forgiving: Can accommodate minor settlement and ground movement
• Readily Available: Materials and expertise widely accessible

The High-Speed Challenge: Why Ballast Becomes Problematic Above 300 km/h

As train speeds increase, ballasted track faces significant technical limitations that become critical safety concerns above 300 km/h.

The Ballast Flight Phenomenon

What is Ballast Flight?

When train speed exceeds 260 km/h, the probability of ballast motion increases dramatically. This phenomenon, known as ballast flight or flying ballast, occurs when aerodynamic forces from passing trains lift ballast stones from the track bed.

The Physics Behind the Problem:

When high-speed trains pass over ballasted track, they create intense aerodynamic effects:

1. Underbody Airflow: Air velocity under trains traveling at 300-350 km/h reaches approximately 25-30 m/s
2. Suction Effect: The high-velocity air creates low-pressure zones that can overcome the weight of ballast stones
3. Track Vibration: Combined with track vibration from the train, stones become more susceptible to aerodynamic lift

Serious Consequences:

• Safety Hazards: Flying stones can strike the underside of trains, causing damage to equipment
• Infrastructure Damage: Ballast can damage signals, switches, and other trackside equipment
• Worker Safety: Railway maintenance personnel face injury risks from projectile stones
• Operational Disruptions: Requires reduced speeds or increased maintenance

Additional High-Speed Ballast Limitations

Beyond ballast flight, traditional ballasted track faces other challenges at very high speeds:

Track Geometry Deterioration:

• Constant high-speed traffic causes faster ballast degradation and settlement
• Ballast vibration rates of 20-26 mm/s have been observed on new high-speed ballasted rails, compared to standard values of 10-15 mm/s
• Requires more frequent and costly maintenance interventions

Material Breakdown:

• "Sunburn" or weathering causes ballast stones to develop surface cracks
• Fine particles are generated through crushing and abrasion
• Fine particles can be sucked out of the track by passing trains at 350 km/h

Speed Limitations: Ballasted tracks are reaching their technological limits at speeds around 360 km/h, making alternative solutions necessary for future higher-speed operations.

Slab track with noise-reducing rail fixings, built by German company Max Bögl, on the Nürnberg–Ingolstadt high-speed line - This file is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 2.0 Germany license

The Modern Solution: Slab Track Technology

What is Slab Track?

Slab track, also called ballastless track, is a railway track infrastructure where the traditional elastic combination of sleepers and ballast is replaced by a rigid construction of concrete or asphalt.

Basic Structure:

Instead of stones, slab track systems use:

• Concrete or Asphalt Slab: A rigid base layer that distributes loads
• Rails: Either discretely supported on concrete sleepers or continuously embedded
• Elastic Components: Pads, bearings, or boots that provide necessary flexibility
• Substructure Layers: Frost protection, hydraulic-bonded layers, and prepared subgrade

How Slab Track Works

The fundamental difference is that slab track transfers loads through a continuous rigid structure rather than through individual stone particles. Resilience (the "give" that prevents track damage) comes from carefully engineered elastic components rather than the ballast layer itself.

Common Slab Track Systems:

1. RHEDA 2000 (Germany): Uses bi-block concrete sleepers embedded in a concrete slab
2. Shinkansen Slab Track (Japan): Pioneered for bullet train operations
3. BÖGL (Germany): Features prefabricated concrete slabs connected by mortar
4. CRTS Systems (China): Multiple generations (I, II, III) used extensively on Chinese high-speed rail

Advantages of Slab Track for High-Speed Rail

Operational Benefits:

• Higher Speed Capability: Designed for speeds of 350 km/h and used on lines with speeds of 350 km/h
• Eliminates Ballast Flight: No loose stones to become airborne
• Consistent Geometry: Track geometry remains highly consistent and difficult to disturb once set
• Reduced Vibration: Better performance in controlling ground-borne vibration

Maintenance Benefits:

• Minimal Routine Maintenance: No requirement for regular realignment of the rails
• Extended Life: Lifespan of up to 100 years compared to 15 years for ballasted track
• Higher Availability: Fewer track closures needed for maintenance work
• Worker Safety: Less time required trackside reduces accident exposure

Structural Advantages:

• Reduced Construction Depth: Particularly beneficial in tunnels
• Lower Dead Load: Important for bridges and viaducts
• Better Load Distribution: Improved performance under heavy traffic

Challenges and Considerations

Higher Initial Costs: Deutsche Bahn estimated in 2015 that construction costs of ballastless tracks are in many cases 28 percent higher than traditional superstructure. However, lifecycle costs are generally lower due to reduced maintenance.

Construction Precision: Slab track must be concreted with a tolerance of ±1.0 mm, requiring highly skilled construction and quality control.

Limited Flexibility: Once concrete is set, correcting track geometry becomes difficult and expensive, unlike ballasted track which can be adjusted through tamping.

Transition Zones: Special care is needed where slab track meets ballasted track (such as at tunnel portals or bridge approaches) to prevent abrupt changes in track stiffness.

Global Adoption

Slab track has seen widespread adoption for high-speed rail:

• China: Nearly 29,000 km of ballastless systems constructed in less than a decade, accounting for over 80% of all slab tracks worldwide
• Japan: Approaching 100% use of slab track on high-speed lines
• Germany: Extensive use on high-speed corridors, including the Nuremberg-Ingolstadt line
• Spain: Madrid-Barcelona and other AVE high-speed routes

Aerodynamic Sleepers - copyright ADIF

The Latest Innovation: Aerodynamic Sleepers (Aerotraviesas)

Spain's Breakthrough Solution

While much of the world has moved to slab track to eliminate ballast flight, Spanish infrastructure manager ADIF, in partnership with engineering firm SENER, has developed an innovative alternative: the Aerotraviesa or aerodynamic sleeper.

The Aerotraviesa Project

The Aurígidas Project, led by SENER under Spain's National Plan for Scientific Research, Development and Technological Innovation, developed the Aerotraviesa to reduce the flying ballast phenomenon.

Development Partners:

• ADIF (Spanish railway infrastructure manager)
• SENER (engineering consultancy)
• Polytechnic University of Madrid
• CIDAUT Foundation

How Aerodynamic Sleepers Work

Design Innovation:

The aerosleeper's geometric shape modifies the speed field on the ballast in the area between sleepers and minimizes the presence of ballast particles on them. Rather than using a conventional rectangular cross-section, the aerotraviesa features specially contoured surfaces that manage airflow.

Performance Improvements:

The aerodynamic design delivers measurable benefits:

• Reduced Downforce: Reduces downforce by 21% in the space immediately above the ballast bed
• Speed Increase: Enables a 12% increase in train operating speed
• Equivalent Performance: The downforce at 330 km/h with current sleepers equals that generated by the aerosleeper at 370 km/h

Real-World Application

Madrid-Barcelona High-Speed Line:

Spain has announced plans to install aerodynamic sleepers on the Madrid-Barcelona high-speed line as part of upgrades to enable 350 km/h operation. This represents a practical alternative to complete slab track conversion.

Strategic Advantages:

The aerotraviesa offers several benefits over full slab track conversion:

1. Retrofit Capability: Can be installed on existing ballasted high-speed lines
2. Lower Cost: Avoids the high expense of complete track replacement
3. Proven Ballast Infrastructure: Retains the flexibility and drainage benefits of ballast
4. Speed Extension: Allows existing infrastructure to support higher speeds

Technical Specifications

The aerodynamic sleeper uses a design that reduces the effect of flying ballast at speeds greater than 300 km/h. The patent covers the specific geometry that manages underbody airflow to prevent ballast destabilization.

Target Application:

The technology specifically addresses the challenge of operating trains above 300 km/h on ballasted track, a speed threshold where traditional sleepers create problematic aerodynamic conditions.

Implications for Canada: The ALTO High-Speed Rail Project

Canada is no longer just considering high-speed rail—it's actively developing what will become the country's first true high-speed rail network. The ALTO project represents a transformative opportunity to apply these advanced track technologies in the Canadian context.

The ALTO High-Speed Rail Network

Announced by Prime Minister Justin Trudeau in February 2025, ALTO (formerly known as the High Frequency Rail project) is a high-speed rail line connecting Quebec City to Toronto, spanning approximately 1,000 km with trains reaching speeds of 300 to 350 km/h—more than double the 160 km/h maximum speed of current VIA Rail services.

Network Details:

The ALTO network will serve seven cities with dedicated stations:

• Toronto
• Peterborough
• Ottawa
• Montreal
• Laval
• Trois-Rivières
• Quebec City

By traveling at speeds up to 300 km/h on dedicated passenger tracks, ALTO would reduce travel times between Toronto and Montreal to approximately three hours, compared to the current 5.5-hour drive or longer rail journey. Montreal to Quebec City travel time would drop to approximately 1.5 hours versus 3.25 hours by car.

Project Structure:

ALTO is a federal Crown corporation created to oversee the project's development, construction, financing, operation, and maintenance. In February 2025, the Cadence consortium (including French state-owned rail operator SNCF Voyageurs, Air Canada, CDPQ Infra, AtkinsRéalis, Keolis, and SYSTRA) was selected as the private developer partner after a multi-year procurement process.

Track Technology Decisions for ALTO

The ALTO project presents a critical opportunity to apply the track technologies discussed in this article. With target speeds of 300-350 km/h, ALTO's designers must address the exact challenges that have driven innovation in European and Asian high-speed rail:

The 300 km/h Threshold:

ALTO's planned operating speeds place it squarely in the range where ballast flight becomes a serious concern. This means the project team must carefully consider:

1. Slab Track Sections: For segments requiring maximum speed and reliability (particularly the Toronto-Montreal core), slab track offers proven performance at 350 km/h with minimal maintenance requirements over a projected 60-100 year service life.

2. Aerodynamic Sleeper Technology: For sections where existing corridors might be upgraded or where cost considerations favor ballasted track, Spain's aerotraviesa technology could allow ALTO to achieve 300+ km/h speeds while retaining the flexibility and lower initial costs of traditional ballast.

3. Hybrid Approach: Like many European networks, ALTO might employ different track technologies based on local conditions—slab track in tunnels and urban areas, aerodynamic sleepers or traditional ballasted track in rural sections operating at lower speeds.

Canadian Context Considerations

Climate Challenges:

• Slab track requires robust frost protection layers in Canada's harsh winter climate
• Freeze-thaw cycles demand careful engineering of both slab and ballasted systems
• Ballasted track's superior drainage becomes crucial in regions with heavy precipitation and spring melt

Economic Scale: At an estimated cost of $80-120 billion, ALTO is significantly more expensive per kilometer than comparable European high-speed lines. Track technology choices will significantly impact both construction costs and long-term operational expenses.

Economic Benefits: The project is expected to deliver 50,000 jobs over ten years and $15-27 billion in economic benefits over 60 years, while using electrified track to reduce emissions from car and air travel in the Toronto-Quebec City corridor.

Network Integration:

• ALTO will operate on mostly dedicated passenger tracks, minimizing conflicts with freight rail
• Connection points with existing VIA Rail services require careful transition zone design
• Maintenance facilities and training programs must support new track technologies

Learning from International Experience

The ALTO project benefits from decades of international high-speed rail experience. Key lessons include:

From Japan (Shinkansen):

• Pioneering use of slab track on high-speed lines, approaching 100% adoption
• Proven reliability in earthquake-prone regions (relevant to British Columbia)
• Integration of ballastless track in tunnels and elevated structures

From Europe (TGV, ICE, AVE):

• Successful mixed-technology approaches based on local conditions
• Experience operating in cold climates (German and Swiss high-speed lines)
• Cost-effective retrofit strategies for existing corridors

From China:

• Rapid deployment of slab track systems (29,000 km in less than a decade)
• Large-scale prefabrication techniques reducing construction time
• Integration of multiple slab track system types based on requirements

From Spain (AVE):

• Development of aerodynamic sleepers as cost-effective solution for 300+ km/h operation
• Experience with slab track in diverse climate conditions
• Successful public-private partnership models

Timeline and Development

The co-development phase was launched on March 31, 2025, with the Cadence consortium working alongside ALTO to design the system in collaboration with VIA Rail and Transport Canada. The design phase is expected to take approximately four years, followed by phased construction with the goal of making initial segments operational as quickly as possible.

Conclusion

The evolution from traditional ballasted track to modern slab track and innovative solutions like aerodynamic sleepers represents a century of railway engineering advancement. As trains have become faster, the limitations of loose stone ballast have become increasingly apparent, particularly above 300 km/h where ballast flight poses serious safety and operational challenges.

For Canadians considering high-speed rail development, understanding these technologies is crucial. Slab track offers the most robust solution for very high-speed operations, with proven performance on networks in China, Japan, and Europe. Meanwhile, innovations like Spain's aerotraviesa demonstrate that thoughtful engineering can extend the capabilities of traditional infrastructure.

The choice between these technologies depends on specific corridor requirements, speed targets, traffic volumes, climate conditions, and economic constraints. What's clear is that modern high-speed rail demands sophisticated track systems engineered to handle the unique challenges of 21st-century rail transport.

As Canada moves forward with rail modernization, these proven international technologies provide a roadmap for building safe, efficient, and sustainable high-speed rail infrastructure for generations to come.

Paul Langan, Founder High Speed Rail Canada

---

References

1. ALTO Train. (n.d.). Shaping Canada's Future With a High-Speed Train. Retrieved from https://www.altotrain.ca/en

2. Transport Canada. (2025). Alto (formerly VIA HFR - VIA TGF Inc.). Government of Canada. Retrieved from https://tc.canada.ca/en/corporate-services/transparency/briefing-documents-transport-canada/2025/coporate-structure/crown-corporations/alto-formerly-via-hfr-via-tgf-inc

3. Wikipedia. (2025). Alto (high-speed rail). Retrieved from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alto_(high-speed_rail)

4. Wikipedia. (2025). High-speed rail in Canada. Retrieved from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-speed_rail_in_Canada

5. SYSTRA. (2025). High speed line ALTO – Canada. Retrieved from https://www.systra.com/en/projects/high-speed-line-alto-canada/

6. Railway Gazette International. (2025). Canada aims to start Alto high speed rail construction in four years. Retrieved from https://www.railwaygazette.com/high-speed/canada-aims-to-start-alto-high-speed-rail-construction-in-four-years/69578.article

7. Mass Transit. (2025). Government of Canada selects Cadence as preferred private developer partner for Alto rail project. Retrieved from https://www.masstransitmag.com/rail/infrastructure/article/55270094/government-of-canada-selects-cadence-as-preferred-private-developer-partner-for-alto-rail-project

8. Railway Technology. (2025). Cadence Consortium to develop Alto high-speed rail project in Canada. Retrieved from https://www.railway-technology.com/news/cadence-alto-high-speed-rail/

9. High Speed Rail Alliance. (2025). Alto, Canada's high speed rail project, holds first public meeting. Retrieved from https://www.hsrail.org/blog/canadas-alto-high-speed-rail-project-hold-public-meeting/

10. UIC (International Union of Railways). (n.d.). Ballasted track. High-Speed Rail Database.

11. Sadeghi, J. (2016). "Field investigation on dynamics of railway track pre-stressed concrete sleepers." Advances in Structural Engineering, 19(8), 1236-1249.

12. European Court of Auditors. (2018). Special Report: A European high-speed rail network: Not a reality but an ineffective patchwork.

13. Deutsche Bahn AG. (2015). Ballastless track systems for high-speed railways. Technical Documentation.

14. Kwon, H. B., & Park, C. S. (2006). "An experimental study on the relationship between ballast-flying phenomenon and strong wind under high-speed train." Proceedings of the World Congress on Railway Research.

15. ADIF (Administrador de Infraestructuras Ferroviarias). (2019). Aerotraviesa: Aerodynamic Railway Sleeper Development. Technical Report with SENER Engineering.

16. China Railway Corporation. (2020). Development and Application of Ballastless Track Technology in China. Beijing: China Railway Publishing House.

17. Esveld, C. (2001). Modern Railway Track (2nd ed.). MRT-Productions.

18. Railway Technical Research Institute. (2013). Shinkansen Slab Track Systems: Design and Performance. Tokyo, Japan.

---

For more information on Canada's rail infrastructure planning and high-speed rail initiatives, visit ALTO Train at www.altotrain.ca or consult Transport Canada resources.