Skip to main content

Hyperloop Nine Years Later and the Debacle Continues


Elon Musk Had An Idea

Elon Musk in 2013 released his white paper for his latest technology titled "Hyperloop." Red flags should have been raised immediately has Elon stated he would not be developing the technology himself. He did host some student competitions but even those have been cancelled.

Elon Musk student hyperloop competition
Elon Musk student hyperloop competition in 2017 - credit Engadget

High Speed Rail Canada released in 2020 a paper critical of the Hyperloop technology. It can be viewed here.  Some of the still pertinent safety issues were outlined including:

  • Security Issues
  • Sudden Decompression
  • Thermal Expansion
  • Pressure
  • Emergency Exits
  • G-Force and Illness
  • Passenger Capacity
  • Hyperloop Technology Needed That Does Not Exist Including: Hyperloop High Speed Switches, Airlock Systems, Turbomolecular Pumps

 Let us look at the two big players today in the hyperloop industry and see how they are progressing.

Hyperloop Transportation Technologies

Started in 2013, Hyperloop  Transportation Technologies company has been at the forefront of promoting hyperloop. 

Hyperloop technologies UAE partnership

Their website's technology page is heavily dominated by CGI (computer-generated-images)  as they have no working prototype.

The reality is they have been great at announcing dates for start up of systems that have not or will not occur. 

In 2019, they announced  Passengers will be able to travel from Dubai to Abu Dhabi in 15 minutes at a maximum speed of 1,000kmph in 2023.

In 2019, Bibop Gresta, chairman of Hyperloop Transportation Technologies (HyperloopTT) has said that Hyperloop trials could begin as early as 2020 while commercial operations are likely to commence by 2023. See photo above of signing of the agreement with Talal Al Dhiyebi CEP Aldar.

Hyperlooptt  is still a company with unproven concepts.

Virgin Hyperloop

Hyperloop technology flaws
Virgin's now cancelled Hyperloop passenger system.

The other big company in the hyperloop space is Virgin Hyperloop. Their claim to fame is their 2 person pod that travelled along a short track in 2020.  However, just two short years later and they have abandoned plans for moving people and now are focusing on moving cargo. Perhaps some of the critical flaws in the hyperloop technology played a factor in the decision.

In the process Virgin laid off half their staff and their CEO and co-founder Josh Giegel stepped down

So it is totally up to the private sector how they want to spend and lose their millions of dollars and hyperloop is a proven money pit with no foreseeable return on investment. Governments in autocratic societies, where people have no power, also can spend their money on the hyperloop fantasy. 

Most of us knew in 2013, that Hyperloop could not live up to the hype.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Canada-USA High Speed Possibilities - Part 1 Montreal-Boston

High Speed Rail Canada - High Noon for High Speed Rail Series Canada-USA High Speed Possibilities - Part 1 Montreal-Boston Paul Langan, Founder High Speed Rail Canada http://highspeedrail.ca/ - 11/11/09 The High Speed Rail (HSR) passenger rail renewal is coming to North America the question is where will it be implemented.I would like to examine the cross border opportunities for HSR that have been put forward. Four possible passenger rail corridors connecting Canada and the USA exist. They are; Vancouver BC to Seattle WA , Windsor ON to Detroit MI , Montreal QC - New York NY and Montreal QC-Boston MA. I would like to examine the Montreal-Boston HSR proposal first. All these cross border corridors share three significant fundamental challenges. 1. A multitude of political stakeholders - The more governments that are involved the process the slower the ability to get change to occur. This is especially true between Canada and the USA where dialogue and cooperation on passenger ra

High Speed Rail Canada releases VIA Rail Canada, Infrastructure Bank High Frequency Rail Project Study Free Download

  Anyone who has followed former VIA Rail President, now Siemens employee, Yves Desjardins-Siciliano high-frequency rail crusade in Ontario and Quebec were left with more questions than answers. Details of the plan were scare and kept secret from the public. Yves anti high-speed rail speeches were well documented.  VIA Rail Canada's map on the alternative, high frequency rail, changed frequently and often. Claims of  improved frequencies, travel times, speeds were touted without any quality evidence to support it. High Speed Rail Canada releases this study to show just how far VIA Rail will go to keep the public in the dark about their proposed plan. This study is so  heavily redacted it is almost worthless. Why the secrets? Perhaps this high frequency rail plan was just a  pipe dream of Mr. Desjardins-Siciliano. Reminder the study is NOT about high-speed rail. Click HERE to view and download the study.  Canadians deserve better.

Prairie Link - New High Speed Rail Proposal for Calgary-Red Deer-Edmonton

Fantastic news out of Alberta! The companies EllisDon and AECOM are proposing a high speed rail line between Calgary, Red Deer and Edmonton. Here is their press release. We will be watching this closely. Edmonton, AB, July 8, 2021—EllisDon, a world-leading construction services and infrastructure development company, announced today that they have formed a partnership to advance the development of high-speed rail connecting Edmonton, Red Deer, and Calgary in Alberta, Canada. EllisDon and its team took the initiative to propose the project within the Government of Alberta’s Unsolicited Proposal Guidelines and Framework. "The notion of high-speed rail — a proven technology around the world — connecting Edmonton, Red Deer, and Calgary in Alberta is not new, but we believe that its time has come. We have built a team with both the capacity and faith in the future of our province to advance it in a meaningful way for Albertans," said Jeffrey Hansen-Carlson, Director with EllisDon